The History, Menu, And Experience Of St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis

St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis is a dining institution that has stood the test of time, serving as a beacon of culinary excellence in downtown Indianapolis. Renowned for its rich history, impeccable service, and legendary shrimp cocktail, St. Elmo has become more than just a restaurant—it's a destination. Whether you're a local resident or a visitor seeking a memorable meal, St. Elmo offers an experience that combines tradition, flavor, and ambiance in a way that few establishments can replicate.

Established in 1902, St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis is one of the oldest steakhouses in the United States. Over the years, it has gained national acclaim for its traditional American steakhouse menu and unwavering commitment to quality. Its name has become synonymous with fine dining, earning accolades from food critics, celebrities, and everyday diners alike. Each visit to St. Elmo feels like stepping back in time while still enjoying the modern comforts of a world-class restaurant.

From its iconic neon sign to the vibrant buzz inside its walls, St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis has mastered the art of creating a dining experience that blends history with innovation. Guests are invited to indulge in USDA Prime steaks, world-famous appetizers, and expertly crafted cocktails, all while soaking in the character of a restaurant that has been a cornerstone of Indianapolis culture for over a century. This article delves into the history, menu, ambiance, and everything else that makes St. Elmo Steak House a must-visit destination.

Table of Contents

1. History of St. Elmo Steak House
2. Iconic Menu Items
3. The Famous Shrimp Cocktail
4. The Steaks: A Cut Above
5. Craft Cocktails and Wine Selection
6. Dining Experience and Ambiance
7. Location and Architecture
8. Recognition and Awards
9. Community Involvement and Charity
10. St. Elmo and Indianapolis Culture
11. Visiting Tips and Reservations
12. Celebrity Visits and Pop Culture
13. Frequently Asked Questions
14. Conclusion

History of St. Elmo Steak House

St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis was founded in 1902 by Joe Stahr and has been serving diners for over 120 years. Its namesake, St. Elmo, is the patron saint of sailors, symbolizing the restaurant's steadfast dedication to quality and tradition. Originally a tavern, St. Elmo evolved into a steakhouse that has since become an integral part of Indianapolis’ dining scene.

Over the decades, the restaurant has changed ownership but never its core philosophy. In 1986, Craig Huse and Steve Huse took over the establishment with a vision to preserve its history while elevating its offerings. Their efforts have paid off, as St. Elmo has become a nationally recognized name, catering to everyone from local diners to visiting celebrities and dignitaries.

With its red leather booths, dark wood interiors, and vintage photographs adorning the walls, St. Elmo retains the charm of its early 20th-century roots. The restaurant is a living museum of Indianapolis’ culinary history and continues to set the standard for steakhouses nationwide.

Iconic Menu Items

The menu at St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis is a celebration of classic American steakhouse fare, prepared with the finest ingredients and meticulous attention to detail. While the restaurant is best known for its steaks, the menu also features a variety of appetizers, seafood dishes, and desserts that have become beloved by patrons.

• USDA Prime Steaks
• The Spicy Shrimp Cocktail
• Fresh Seafood Selections
• Signature Side Dishes
• Decadent Desserts

Each dish is crafted to perfection, ensuring that every bite is a memorable one. Whether you're dining solo or celebrating a special occasion, the menu offers something for everyone.

The Famous Shrimp Cocktail

The shrimp cocktail at St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis is legendary, and for good reason. Featuring jumbo shrimp paired with a fiery, horseradish-laden cocktail sauce, this appetizer has become a rite of passage for first-time visitors. The sauce's intense heat has earned it a reputation as one of the spiciest in the country, offering a culinary thrill that diners won’t soon forget.

Despite its simplicity, the shrimp cocktail encapsulates the ethos of St. Elmo: high-quality ingredients and bold flavors. It's a dish that has been featured on numerous food shows and is often cited as a must-try item when visiting Indianapolis.

The Steaks: A Cut Above

St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis takes pride in serving only the finest USDA Prime beef, aged to perfection and cooked to order. Each steak is seasoned simply with kosher salt and cracked black pepper, allowing the natural flavors of the meat to shine. Popular cuts include the filet mignon, ribeye, and New York strip, all of which are expertly prepared by a team of skilled chefs.

In addition to the traditional cuts, the restaurant also offers specialty dishes like the bone-in tomahawk steak and the surf-and-turf combination. Pairing these steaks with the restaurant’s signature sides, such as creamed spinach or au gratin potatoes, elevates the meal to a fine dining experience like no other.

Craft Cocktails and Wine Selection

The bar at St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis is as iconic as its menu, offering a wide range of craft cocktails and an extensive wine list. Signature drinks like the Elmo Cola, made with a splash of cherry vanilla bourbon, have become favorites among regulars. Meanwhile, the wine selection features bottles from around the world, carefully curated to complement the menu’s flavors.

For those who prefer a non-alcoholic option, the restaurant also offers a variety of mocktails and soft beverages, ensuring that every guest can find a drink to suit their taste.

Dining Experience and Ambiance

The atmosphere at St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis is both inviting and refined, making it an ideal setting for everything from business dinners to romantic evenings. With its dim lighting, elegant decor, and attentive service, the restaurant creates an environment that is both comfortable and luxurious.

Guests are encouraged to dress in business casual attire, adding to the overall sense of occasion. The staff’s professionalism and warmth further enhance the experience, ensuring that every diner feels like a valued guest.

Location and Architecture

Located in the heart of downtown Indianapolis, St. Elmo Steak House is housed in a historic building that reflects the city’s rich architectural heritage. Its iconic neon sign has become a landmark, drawing diners from near and far. The interior, with its vintage charm and modern touches, provides the perfect backdrop for an unforgettable meal.

Recognition and Awards

Over the years, St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis has received numerous accolades, including recognition from the James Beard Foundation and features in prestigious food publications. Its commitment to excellence has also earned it a loyal following among locals and visitors alike.

Community Involvement and Charity

St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis is deeply committed to giving back to the community. Through various charitable initiatives and partnerships, the restaurant supports local organizations and causes, further solidifying its role as a pillar of the Indianapolis community.

St. Elmo and Indianapolis Culture

As a cornerstone of Indianapolis’ dining scene, St. Elmo Steak House has played a significant role in shaping the city’s cultural identity. From hosting high-profile events to serving as a meeting place for locals, the restaurant has become an integral part of the city’s fabric.

Visiting Tips and Reservations

To make the most of your visit to St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis, it’s recommended to make a reservation in advance, especially during peak dining hours. The restaurant also offers private dining options for special occasions and group events.

Celebrity Visits and Pop Culture

Over the years, St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis has welcomed a host of celebrities, athletes, and public figures, further cementing its status as a dining destination. The restaurant has also been featured in various media outlets, including television shows and movies, adding to its cultural significance.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is St. Elmo Steak House famous for? St. Elmo is best known for its USDA Prime steaks and spicy shrimp cocktail.
2. Is St. Elmo Steak House suitable for families? Yes, the restaurant welcomes families and offers a kid-friendly menu.
3. Does St. Elmo offer vegetarian options? While primarily a steakhouse, St. Elmo does offer vegetarian side dishes and salads.
4. Can I order takeout from St. Elmo Steak House? Yes, the restaurant offers takeout and delivery options.
5. Is there a dress code? Business casual attire is recommended.
6. Does St. Elmo Steak House accommodate dietary restrictions? Yes, the staff is happy to work with guests to accommodate dietary needs.

Conclusion

St. Elmo Steak House Indianapolis is more than just a place to eat—it’s a slice of history, a symbol of community, and a testament to the art of fine dining. With its exceptional menu, welcoming ambiance, and storied past, St. Elmo continues to captivate diners from all walks of life. Whether you’re a steak aficionado or a first-time visitor, a meal at St. Elmo is an experience you won’t soon forget.